Belly Up: A Reflection from the November 2026 Gender and Spirituality Retreat

November 16, 2026

by Ray Hommeyer

Photo: Salmon Jumping Up the Brooks Falls at Katmai National Park, Alaska.

https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/best-places-to-see-the-salmon-run.html





“Salmon have much to teach us about the art of facing things. In swimming up waterfalls, these remarkable creatures seem to defy gravity. It is an amazing thing to behold. A closer look reveals a wisdom for all beings who want to thrive. 

What the salmon somehow know is how to turn their underside – from center to tail – into the powerful current coming at them, which hits them squarely, and the impact then launches them out and further up the waterfall; to which their reaction is, again, to turn their underside back into the powerful current that, of course, again hits them squarely; and this successive impact launches them further out and up the waterfall. 

Their leaning into what they face bounces them further and further along their unlikely journey. From a distance, it seems magical, as if these mighty fish are flying, conquering their element. In actuality, they are deeply at one with their element, vibrantly and thoroughly engaged in a compelling dance of turning-toward-and-being-hit-squarely that moves them through water and air to the very source of their nature. In terms useful to the life of the spirit, the salmon are constantly faithful in exposing their underside to the current coming at them. Mysteriously, it is the physics of this courage that enable them to move through life as they know it so directly. 

We can learn from this very active paradox; for we, too, must be as faithful to living in the open if we are to stay real in the face of our daily experience. In order not to be swept away by what the days bring, we, too, must find a way to lean into the forces that hit us so squarely. The salmon offer us a way to face truth without shutting down. 

They show us how leaning into our experience, though we don’t like the hit, moves us on. Time and again, though we’d rather turn away, it is the impact of being revealed, through our willingness to be vulnerable, that enables us to experience both mystery and grace.”


From The Art of Facing Things, by Mark Nepo


There is a lot of hard work yet ahead of us to continue undermining fascism and build thriving and just communities for all. And, I do think that this week, post-election, is a celebration of many people practicing swimming up waterfalls, belly-first. So many people worked hard organizing for the results we got this week. Many of us in this congregation put in a lot of time, energy, vulnerability, and effort gearing up for this recent election. A few friends of mine were part of a deep canvass effort in the Rochester area to talk with previous Trump voters who have become dissatisfied with the state of things. My friends doing this work identify as queer and knew they were going to talk with people who may not believe in their inherent worth and dignity or access to equal rights. One of my friends wrote that during this experience they did hear a lot of things that saddened them and made them realize how deep the impact of hateful propaganda can go. Some members of the team were unfortunately verbally assaulted by people whose hearts have been hardened by hate. And, yet, the team also had so many incredible, heart-opening, transformative conversations with 100s of people, which resulted in 1,600 votes for the progressive candidate.


My friend writes: “I can also picture the faces of people I talked to who would be written off by (liberals), progressives and leftists as immovable or not worth trying to reach. Checked out. (Our team) met those people openly, and they opened up to us. Together we had vulnerable conversations and disagreements, and at the end, (found) that we could both support the same (candidate).” 


The political move to divide and control is one of the oldest in the playbook. The amount of trans scapegoating that has taken place these last two years (plus) has been deeply troubling, scary, and painful. And, I am amazed, grateful, and relieved that many people across our country have united around basic needs and rights for all people and not gotten distracted by such divisive hate. This isn’t only a win for those of us who are queer and trans. I really believe this is a win for all of us, because, regardless of our gender, we are all impacted by people in power trying to control our bodies and chosen relationships. Instead of choosing fear and division this week, so many of us choose faithful relationships. 


Mark Nepo’s imagery of the salmon leaping up waterfalls is both an example of and an invitation towards just such faithful relationships. 


What else does a religious community ask of us other than the practice of turning, belly up, to one another and, together, facing the hits that land forcefully? What else does a religious community ask of us other than the practice of vulnerability and courage in our listening, in our speech, and in our relationships?


Our Gender and Spirituality retreat was intended to be an opportunity to expand and linger in just such a practice, slowing down to wonder and play and hear and try and imagine. 


At Grace, we practice using various words, images, and names for God. Still, many of us were taught about God, implicitly or explicitly, through limited male gendered language and rites. And, maybe even that to be male meant to be closer to God.


An impactful theologian during my seminary studies – Jewish and feminist scholar Judith Plaskow – challenges these patriarchal norms while also complexifying them. In response to replacing male gendered terminology with female gendered terminology, she warns us against reinforcing a simplistic binary (woman/man). 


This binary which, at its core, is inherently misogynistic—privileges man, male, masculinity over that which is woman, female, feminine, as well as what is transgressive between and beyond. Instead of falling into this well-worn trap, however, Plaskow invites us to practice holding all of it. Instead of suggesting people only neutralize and remove all gendered terms, Plaskow invites us to practice being expansive–to play with and between genders, to envision a gender transgressive divinity, to recognize, as she says, “the flexibility of and shifts in God’s gender. We can think of God as masculine, feminine, female, male, both, neither, in various combinations, (all of the above), and in terms that have nothing to do with gender." 


While a patriarchal portrayal of God has reinforced power structures of male dominance, I believe that all people, including men, are also negatively impacted by dominant gender norms. All of us deserve to experience our own wholeness and expansiveness, which, as we explored yesterday, may not fit within a particular box of normative gender presentation. 


How might the practice of envisioning a gender transgressive divinity also help us to transcend other rigid binary structures which feed into heteronormative-patriarchy, as well as white supremacy and capitalist economic injustice? In particular, today, what might this practice of envisioning a gender transgressive divinity OPEN in us regarding our personal relationships with gender?


Writer Jen Silverman exemplifies play and creativity in her response to the question “what is your gender?” She writes: “My gender is denim, my gender is The Doubtful Guest, my gender is sunflower yellow... is the Six of Swords. My gender is… fill-in-the-blank.”


This is what we too are invited to engage, in the sacred space of our congregation, with these people with whom we commune together. We are asked to flex our muscles of imagination. Such re-imagining is not only a reclamation of what has been, it’s also a way to co-create and begin to inhabit new realities for us and for our children and for our children’s children.


In the same essay, Jen writes, “I’ve begun to realize that choosing a future is about choosing more and more daring acts of imagination. It is pure faith, maybe, that the right words will come last; that what arrives first will be fantasies and dreams, inchoate but powerful. (For) what is faith, if not instinct plus hope?” 


Today and all days, we are invited to linger in this place of fantasies and dreams, drawing on memories and past experiences to playfully envision new routes of connection and possibility. We are invited to practice turning our bellies a little more towards what scares us and imagining the impact propelling us closer to the waterfall that is this life journey.


As we practice and play and faithfully imagine together today, may we listen deeply to one another and to the sacred within, among and beyond us. May we share truthfully in ways that honor complexity. May we build trust genuinely and compassionately. And may we ground into our religious roots while wildly dreaming into our collective future. 

By Susan Daughtry • November 12, 2026
Courageous Public Discipleship group's work before and after the midterm elections
By Susan Daughtry • November 11, 2026
A Conversation with The Rev. William Barber
By Susan Daughtry • November 11, 2026
Post-Election Thoughts